South Street Brewery - a must-see in Charlottesville!

While at Mellow Mushroom in Charlottesville, I noticed South Street Brewery's "Satan's Pony" red ale on draft. I do love red ales, but I opted not to try it because I discovered the brewery was within walking distance of my hotel, and that I should check out the place myself. I had two other nights to explore the town, so I put it on the calendar and opted to give this place a full review. After Friday's sessions (which included a well-attended workshop on student advocacy presented by yours truly) I headed out for some beer and a bite to eat.

The brewery itself is located on South Street in Charlottesville, between the Downtown Mall and UVA's campus. It was about a 15 minute walk from my hotel. Tucked away between houses and apartments, the brewery fronts right to the street and occupies an industrial space, maybe a former warehouse. Inside, there's a huge seating area with a fireplace, comfy chairs, high-top tables, and traditional booths. The bar runs almost the whole length of the dining room and has big windows that overlook the brewing area and some nice stainless steel fermenters.

I introduced myself to the bartender, who was great by the way, and took a look at the tap list. They have a pretty respectable draft list here. There's essentially something for everyone - lighter beers, amber ales, red ales, dark stouts, sours. I like these kinds of places because it's fun to see how the brewers approach various styles.

The bartender sees me perusing and says, "would you like a flight?" Why yes, I would. So he proceeds to pour me a 4oz taste of everything on draft. Twelve beers, 48oz of beer total, to start off the night.

No need to do a full review, I'm just going to write a short snapshot of each.

• "Very Plzen Pils", a 4.60% ABV pilsner made with Czech hops, German malts, and lager yeast...My take: delicious. It's light bodied, not too much carbonation, and presents a low level of hop bitterness paired with a really delicious flaked wheat flavor...not toasted, just raw wheat like that Shredded Wheat cereal I had as a kid. This beer is very traditional, super refreshing, and delicious.
• "My Personal Helles" - a 5.20% ABV unfiltered helles lager made with German noble hops and Augustiner Brau yeast...It's a nice take on the German helles lager style, refreshing but also not as light or as fizzy as a pilsner. 
• "Virginia Lager" - a 5.20% ABV lager...Very straightforward but well-balanced. Malt is the biggest tasting note here. I felt it was a little heavy for 5.20%. Not much else to say - it's just a decent, regular lager. 
• "Satan's Pony" - a 5.30% ABV amber ale made with Scottish ale yeast and English hops...In my opinion, pretty hoppy for a red ale. I prefer my red ales on the maltier / sweeter end, but this one is pretty lively. Nice bite on the finish, though, and the flavor sticks around after swallowing. 
• "Slippery When Wit" - a 5.20% ABV witbier / gose hybrid...That's an interesting concept, actually, so I'm curious how they do it. Turns out the gose is the dominant flavor here - lots of sourness on the front end with some lingering minerality. I can taste the wheat, though, so this beer definitely has elements of both witbier and gose. The menu says it's got a "clean finish" but I actually disagree - it's pretty sticky and the flavor clings to your tongue long after swallowing. I actually like this a lot - lighter styles of beers sometimes have the tendency to be too light and fizzy and the flavor fades away quickly...it's nice to see that's not the case here. This would be good to try if you want an introduction to goses. 
• "Sour Poss" - 6.30% ABV fruit beer...Hazy orange in the glass, this beer is definitely kettle-soured and is quite tart. Nice! Lots of grapefruit and hazy yeast notes. I like grapefruit because it adds a nice flavor and texture but doesn't overdo it (like some other grapefruit beers I've had.) 
• "Barhopper" - a 6.80% ABV IPA made with Citra, Simcoe, Centennial, Sorachi Ace, and Azacca hops...Hmm, okay, this is pretty good because it's actually not terribly aggressive. The description makes me think like it's going to be some amped-up hopmonster, but it's actually middle of the road and presents some decent bitterness and a touch of resin. 
• "Absolution" - a 4.80% ABV old ale...A touch sweet, this beer is pretty earthy, malty, and flat. A rather-light take on the style (a lot of old ales are quite boozy and syrupy) and while it's a faithful reproduction of the style's flavor profile, I'm missing that bit of "oomph" that comes with some of the stronger old ales. 
• "Dave's Cubano Brown Ale" - a 5.30% ABV brown ale made with Shenandoah Joe's Ethiopian Sidamo coffee...Wow, this is closer to a cold brew coffee than it is to a beer. Full coffee notes throughout, and even a bit of the winey and cherry flavors you get with actual Ethiopian coffee. It's not milky at all, but is soft and easydrinking.  I don't know who Dave is, but this beer is definitely a win for coffee lovers and super tasty. 
• "Aisling Stout" - a 5.60% ABV stout made with Caramalts and oats ...it's pretty subtle, actually. Slightly creamy, not much roasted malts or oily textures. Sorta tastes like a lighter version of Guinness. If I was doing a blind taste test, I'd think this was a light porter maybe. This would be good for stout drinkers looking to get their soft, dark beer fix without the heaviness that stouts sometime bring.
• "Acoustic Kitty" - a 9.07% ABV double India Pale Oat Ale...curious, have never heard that term before. Beer is good though - brassy, so definitely good if you like your DIPAs on the hoppy side. There's a touch of sweetness, but the oats definitely make it maltier and mellows out the hops. But a very full-bodied, yet less bitter, double IPA. 
• "Anastasia's Fantasy, Gingerbread Variant" - a 10.52% Russian imperial stout made with gingerbread....wow, this definitely delivers a massive wave of gingerbread and spices. It's not particularly heavy or boozy, but definitely flavorful and full. Definitely the heaviest thing on the menu. 
• As a bonus, I got to try a mixed firkin of their "Anastasia" and their "Ice Cream Stout"...a neat creamy mixture, definitely softer than the regular "Anastasia." Probably more my speed than the original. Gingerbread is more mellow here, which is good. 

So, looking at the flight as a whole, it was interesting to see the ABVs on the beer....a lot of pretty light beers. That's cool for a couple reasons - not only can we drink more, but it's a nice departure from the super heavy beers you find at some locations. Some brewers like to overload their beers with alcohol to make a boozy wallop, so it's refreshing to have some lighter beers across a variety of styles. Sometimes having a low-alcohol stout is just what the doctor ordered.

Speaking of...biggest winners of the night for me were the firkin "Anastasia" / "Ice Cream Stout" hybrid, the "Dave's Cubano", and the "Very Plzen Pilsner."

The atmosphere is also really great - all the staff I interacted with were warm and inviting, the space is large but feels intimate, and the food was delicious (I had a fancy grilled cheese.) This reminds me a lot of Molly Pitcher - a brewery which has a little something for everyone in a really welcoming spot with good food. If you're ever in Charlottesville, give this place a look!